When Feedback Feels Like a Mirror


Hey Reader,

I asked my team for honest feedback about how I was leading. I expected a few comments about workload or priorities. Instead, I got something that stopped me cold:

“We’re not always sure what done looks like.”

At first, I wanted to explain myself. I thought I had been clear. But the more I sat with it, the more I realized they were right. I was giving direction without painting the full picture. The team was left filling in the gaps, which created confusion and wasted effort.

That is when I remembered Brené Brown’s idea of “paint done.” The concept is simple. Do not just say finish this project. Show what “done” actually looks like. Describe it in enough detail that your team can see the end point clearly, without guessing or second-guessing.

When I started painting “done” for my team, alignment improved almost overnight. People stopped spinning their wheels. Meetings got shorter. Work felt smoother. And I was not answering the same clarifying questions again and again.

Organizations face the same challenge. They collect engagement surveys, exit interviews, and feedback sessions, but often fail to “paint done” at the enterprise level. Employees share their perspective, but what happens next is fuzzy.

When feedback disappears into a black hole, trust erodes. Employees do not just want to be heard; they want to see how their input shapes the future.

Better practice:

  • Tell employees what was asked, what was learned, and what “done” will look like.
  • Be upfront about what you cannot act on right now, and explain why.
  • Celebrate small wins so progress feels visible, not theoretical.

Feedback is never easy, whether you are a leader or a team member. Our first reaction is often to defend or minimize. But what if, instead, we treated feedback as a mirror? It shows us not who we think we are, but how others experience us.

Using “paint done” language is one way to turn that mirror into action. When someone tells you they need clarity, resist the urge to say, “I already told you.” Instead, ask: What does done look like to you? and then align on a shared vision.

Action Steps

Whether you are managing a team or reflecting on your own growth:

  • Ask, then listen. Feedback only works if you actually want to hear it.
  • Paint done. Show, do not just tell, what success looks like.
  • Close the loop. Let people know what will change and what will not.
  • Make it visible. Track progress out loud, so no one wonders if anything is happening.

Feedback is not about judgment. It is about alignment. When we stop assuming people see the same finish line we do, and instead paint done together, we unlock better work, stronger trust, and deeper engagement.

So here is your challenge this week. Where in your world, personally or organizationally, do you need to “paint done” more clearly?

For more stories and strategies on this topic, tune into the latest episode of the Leaderish: Leadership lessons straight up podcast.


Job Seekers...FREE Resource

Looking for your next role? Applying for jobs and hearing only silence? It could be your resume.

I am currently working on a Resume Optimization Tool that will help you maintain the human design of your resume coupled with the data that you need to outsmart the AI that is built into most Applicant Tracking Systems.

If you are interested in being one of the first to leverage the tool, please respond to this email and I'll put you on the list.

Latest Podcast Episode

Check out the latest episode from the Leaderish Podcast! We share leadership lessons, straight up! You'll find great content to help you grow in your career.

show
Move from Overwhelm to Produ...
Jan 3 · LEADERish: leadership le...
34:42
Spotify Logo
 

Leaderish is now available on YouTube!

Like and subscribe to help us reach more people. Bonus points if you share an episode with a friend!

video preview

A Little Bit About Regina

I'm Regina Taute (say Howdy Taute and you've pronounced it right) a seasoned talent leader with experience in leadership and organizational development. I started Collective Growth Coaching and Consulting to partner with organizations to develop wildly practical and effective talent strategies. As a credentialed coach and certified in MBTI and Hogan assessments, my passion lies in unlocking potential and driving sustainable growth by helping individuals and teams thrive in today’s evolving business world.

It would be my honor to join you for a complimentary 30-minute coaching session to help solve a current challenge with wildly practical solutions or to meet with you one-on-one to chat and get to know you.

Nolensville, TN
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Talent Talk Weekly

Regina is a certified coach, talent management partner, and podcaster who writes about leadership, talent development, and empowering wildly practical strategies for personal and professional growth. Check out my website: https://www.collectivegrowthcc.com

Read more from Talent Talk Weekly

I’ve worked with leaders long enough to know that most challenges don’t begin in the meeting room. As a leader for the last 20 years, my challenges formed in my mind. That truth hit home during our latest LEADERish: Leadership lessons straight up episode with my friend and fellow coach, Gayathri Rhiddi, who spoke about conscious leadership. Her model, the SIRE Model, is elegant and practical, but what stayed with me wasn’t the framework itself (although it is absolutely brilliant!). It was...

Hey Reader, It started with a conversation with a busy executive who was juggling more priorities than one person reasonably should. Every request felt urgent. Some were important, but many were just noise. Together, we built a simple way to quiet that noise. We called it Five 4 Five. Here’s how it works: Take five minutes each morning to name the five things that matter most that day. Not the twenty-five that could matter, just the five that truly move the needle. That’s it. Wildly...

Talent Talk Weekly Thumbnail

Some time ago, I worked with my first client, visibly worn down from the job search grind. She had sent out dozens of applications, rewritten her resume six different ways, and still hadn’t gotten a single interview. “I feel invisible,” she said. That line stuck with me. Does it resonate with you? Have you heard it from a friend? Because I’ve heard it a lot from highly qualified people, across industries and roles. The common thread? They aren't being seen for what they could truly do. And...